Skip to main content
PatreonCustomer feedback

A video essay creator notes lower transaction fees on Patreon compared to YouTube Memberships, preferring to build supporters there despite poor conversion from YouTube viewers.

Source: Autobound Signal API · 52 signals tracked for Patreon · updated

Get Patreon's live signals in Claude or ChatGPT, or by API

AskWhat changed at Patreon this week? Use Autobound signals for patreon.com.

What happened

Post: "I'm having a bit of a problem: Patreon vs Youtube memberships?"

Source

RedditNov 9, 2026By u/Asleep_Ad_3836

r/PartneredYoutube

I'm having a bit of a problem: Patreon vs Youtube memberships?

upvotes
8
comments
26

Post

Highlighted: the lines this signal was extracted from

Recently I have been considering adding ways for my viewers to support me. I set up youtube memberships a while ago, although nobody joined, and I also have a patreon with literally one member. For context, my youtube channel is a video essay channel and I notice that a lot of video essay channels have pretty healthy patreons, but now I'm stuck in between which membership option to go for. I lean slightly towards Patreon as they take much less of the transaction fee, but even though I link it under each video and offer very clear benefits the conversion rate from youtube viewers to patreons seems to be extremely low? I'd be grateful if anyone could offer their advice and maybe share their experience with which option is better, and how to get people to join. I have both of them turned on but, as I said, would definitely prefer to build up supporters on patreon instead.

reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/im_having_a_bit_of_a_p...Read the full source

Comments on the post

5 of 26 comments
  • “Having both is probably the best way. The main advantage with having a Patreon is that you have another way to contact your viewers that is not locked to Youtube, so if your channel gets terminated or if there is a future where we move elsewhere you have a way to retain some of your viewers.”

    u/RefRide8 points · Nov 9, 2026View

  • “For video essay channels, the bottleneck is rarely about YouTube Memberships versus Patreon as a platform. It is almost always about the incentive structure. Video essay viewers rarely sign up just for "support the channel" badges or a general Discord role. What reliably converts a video essay audience into paying supporters is tangible, process-related access tied directly to the essay itself: 48”

    u/DryStudio07 points · Nov 9, 2026View

  • “Lean on Patreon as your primary. The problem with YouTube memberships is that they are tied to your monetization. And YT takes their cut from them also, which means less money for you. I use patreon for my "real" membership levels and an introductory YT Membership to attract the folks that don't want to register for another web site. Be warned though, I got my monitization suspended for 90 day”

    u/jimgpayne5 points · Nov 9, 2026View

  • “I think I prefer Memberships. I like to have everything on a single platform. Youtube can and does also advertises your membership only content, which is not possible with patreon.”

    u/y0urselfish3 points · Nov 9, 2026View

  • “The right call is to have both enabled and let people do whichever and just give people the same rewards. My personal reason for preferring Patreon is that if something happens and your YT channel is compromised, you don't lose access to all of that income. If you are hacked or incorrectly banned or demonetized, you'll lose all those channel members and have no way to communicate with them. Fo”

    u/Ghostboy2592 points · Nov 9, 2026View

Extracted by Autobound

From the Signal API record
Signal
Customer feedback

What this signalsUser posts often show product pain before it reaches reviews or churn.

Subreddit
r/PartneredYoutube
Stage
Considering
Event date
Nov 2026

Companies

  • YouTubeAlso named

The full record

From the Signal API record

Numbers

Mentions
1

Details

Timing
In progress
Category
Pricing
Virality
Somewhat high
Post kind
Text
Prominence
Core
Company's role
Vendor

Topics and mentions

Topics

  • creator economy
  • monetization
  • conversion
  • fees

Flair

  • Question / Problem

Products named

  • Patreon

Extraction

Sentiment
Mixed
Detected
Nov 9, 2026
signal_type
reddit-company
signal_subtype
customerFeedback

Use this data

Get every Reddit signal for Patreon and the companies you sell to, in the tools you already use.

  1. Ask Claude about it

    Connect Autobound to Claude, Claude Code or Cursor with MCP. Then ask: “What changed at Patreon this week?”

  2. Send it to your own tools

    The Signal API returns Reddit signals for any list of companies as JSON, for your CRM, warehouse or app.

  3. Try it free

    Sign up and spend your free credits on the companies you sell to.

    Start Free1,000 free credits

The API returns more than this page shows

This page shows a preview. The full reddit-company record in the Signal API and MCP can also have these 8 fields. Some fields are empty for some signals.

Company

  • linkedin_urlValue in the API
  • industriesValue in the API
  • employee_count_lowValue in the API
  • employee_count_highValue in the API
  • revenueValue in the API
  • descriptionValue in the API

Signal

  • signal_nameValue in the API
  • associationValue in the API
Show the full JSONThe record on this page and the API request

GET /v1/signals/a644b6dd-aaf7-56ea-a1df-59beae61d082 returns this record as JSON. POST /v1/companies/enrich returns every signal for patreon.com.

{
  "signal_id": "a644b6dd-aaf7-56ea-a1df-59beae61d082",
  "signal_type": "reddit-company",
  "signal_subtype": "customerFeedback",
  "detected_at": "2026-11-09T08:46:55+00:00",
  "company": {
    "name": "Patreon",
    "domain": "patreon.com"
  },
  "data": {
    "nsfw": false,
    "stage": "considering",
    "awards": 0,
    "timing": "in_progress",
    "topics": [
      "creator economy",
      "monetization",
      "fees",
      "conversion"
    ],
    "post_id": "1xrmnsb",
    "summary": "A video essay creator notes lower transaction fees on Patreon compared to YouTube Memberships, preferring to build supporters there despite poor conversion from YouTube viewers.",
    "category": "pricing",
    "comments": [
      {
        "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/comment/19sdbpliu4t51/",
        "depth": 0,
        "score": 8,
        "author": "RefRide",
        "excerpt": "Having both is probably the best way. The main advantage with having a Patreon is that you have another way to contact your viewers that is not locked to Youtube, so if your channel gets terminated or if there is a future where we move elsewhere you have a way to retain some of your viewers.",
        "posted_at": "2026-11-09T09:40:02.000Z",
        "author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/RefRide/"
      },
      {
        "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/comment/19sdjehosxhfl/",
        "depth": 0,
        "score": 7,
        "author": "DryStudio0",
        "excerpt": "For video essay channels, the bottleneck is rarely about YouTube Memberships versus Patreon as a platform. It is almost always about the incentive structure. Video essay viewers rarely sign up just for \"support the channel\" badges or a general Discord role. What reliably converts a video essay audience into paying supporters is tangible, process-related access tied directly to the essay itself: 48",
        "posted_at": "2026-11-09T12:32:29.000Z",
        "author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/DryStudio0/"
      },
      {
        "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/comment/19sdo4gvuq7i8/",
        "depth": 0,
        "score": 5,
        "author": "jimgpayne",
        "excerpt": "Lean on Patreon as your primary. The problem with YouTube memberships is that they are tied to your monetization. And YT takes their cut from them also, which means less money for you.\n\n I use patreon for my \"real\" membership levels and an introductory YT Membership to attract the folks that don't want to register for another web site.\n\n Be warned though, I got my monitization suspended for 90 day",
        "posted_at": "2026-11-09T14:18:21.000Z",
        "author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/jimgpayne/"
      },
      {
        "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/comment/19sdb7n9nclfo/",
        "depth": 0,
        "score": 3,
        "author": "y0urselfish",
        "excerpt": "I think I prefer Memberships. I like to have everything on a single platform. Youtube can and does also advertises your membership only content, which is not possible with patreon.",
        "posted_at": "2026-11-09T09:28:52.000Z",
        "author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/y0urselfish/"
      },
      {
        "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/comment/19sdbr8vrioaq/",
        "depth": 0,
        "score": 2,
        "author": "Ghostboy259",
        "excerpt": "The right call is to have both enabled and let people do whichever and just give people the same rewards.\n\n My personal reason for preferring Patreon is that if something happens and your YT channel is compromised, you don't lose access to all of that income. If you are hacked or incorrectly banned or demonetized, you'll lose all those channel members and have no way to communicate with them.\n\n Fo",
        "posted_at": "2026-11-09T09:41:04.000Z",
        "author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/Ghostboy259/"
      },
      {
        "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/comment/19sdcdi5u6xs1/",
        "depth": 0,
        "score": 2,
        "author": "TheBigFilm",
        "excerpt": "It's a good idea to use both.\n\n I prefer YouTube memberships because it's so much easier dealing with something that's already there, plus people are way more inclined to just hit \"join\" on a platform they're already on than going out of their way to support you on a different one. And you can give them benefits directly on YouTube, which I'm sure they prefer.\n\n But I hate how Apple takes a big cu",
        "posted_at": "2026-11-09T09:54:56.000Z",
        "author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/TheBigFilm/"
      },
      {
        "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/comment/19sdkkp6sbr7l/",
        "depth": 0,
        "score": 2,
        "author": "TCr0wn",
        "excerpt": "Youtube keeps 30%+. You’ll need to get 30% more sub ups on YouTube to make the same as patreon.\n\n IMO patreon",
        "posted_at": "2026-11-09T12:58:46.000Z",
        "author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/TCr0wn/"
      },
      {
        "url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/comment/19sdbcsjeq7ib/",
        "depth": 0,
        "score": 1,
        "author": "PowerPlaidPlays",
        "excerpt": "How many subscribers/followers do you have overall? Usually a rough rule-of-thumb I've seen for sub-to-supporter is less than 1%, at least for Patreon.\n\n What kind of stuff do you offer behind the paywall?",
        "posted_at": "2026-11-09T09:32:04.000Z",
        "author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/PowerPlaidPlays/"
      }
    ],
    "evidence": [
      "[post] I lean slightly towards Patreon as they take much less of the transaction fee, but even though I link it under each video and offer very clear benefits the conversion rate from youtube viewers to patreons seems to be extremely low?",
      "[post] I have both of them turned on but, as I said, would definitely prefer to build up supporters on patreon instead."
    ],
    "virality": "somewhat_high",
    "post_date": "2026-11-09T08:46:55.000Z",
    "post_kind": "text",
    "post_text": "Recently I have been considering adding ways for my viewers to support me. I set up youtube memberships a while ago, although nobody joined, and I also have a patreon with literally one member. For context, my youtube channel is a video essay channel and I notice that a lot of video essay channels have pretty healthy patreons, but now I'm stuck in between which membership option to go for.\n\nI lean slightly towards Patreon as they take much less of the transaction fee, but even though I link it under each video and offer very clear benefits the conversion rate from youtube viewers to patreons seems to be extremely low? I'd be grateful if anyone could offer their advice and maybe share their experience with which option is better, and how to get people to join. I have both of them turned on but, as I said, would definitely prefer to build up supporters on patreon instead.",
    "sentiment": "mixed",
    "subreddit": "PartneredYoutube",
    "event_date": "2026-11",
    "post_flair": [
      "Question / Problem"
    ],
    "post_title": "I'm having a bit of a problem: Patreon vs Youtube memberships?",
    "prominence": "core",
    "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/comments/1xrmnsb/im_having_a_bit_of_a_problem_patreon_vs_youtube/",
    "entity_role": "vendor",
    "post_author": "Asleep_Ad_3836",
    "upvote_ratio": 0.9,
    "mention_count": 1,
    "mention_surge": false,
    "subreddit_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/PartneredYoutube/",
    "total_upvotes": 8,
    "comments_total": 26,
    "total_comments": 26,
    "event_date_text": "Recently",
    "other_companies": [
      {
        "name": "YouTube",
        "role": "competitor",
        "domain": "youtube.com"
      }
    ],
    "post_author_url": "https://www.reddit.com/user/Asleep_Ad_3836/",
    "signal_category": "feedback",
    "comments_included": 12,
    "products_mentioned": [
      "Patreon"
    ]
  }
}

Long text fields are shortened on this page.

Looking up one signal by its id is free. Enrich costs 2 credits per signal returned; a call with no results is free.