r/hvacadvice
NJ HVAC replacement: Daikin vs Lennox vs Carrier vs Ruud hybrid - looking for advice
- upvotes
- 1
- comments
- 39
Post
Highlighted: the lines this signal was extracted from
My \~4-year-old HVAC system recently had the **outdoor AC/compressor fail**. Over the past 4 years, the system has also needed multiple maintenance/service visits, so the contractors I’ve spoken with are recommending a **full system replacement** rather than replacing only the outdoor unit as the gas (r410a) and equipment is no longer available in the market. Refrigerant leak, this year this gas costing at 200$+tax per pound. I received quotes through **Home Depot’s referred contractor,** **Lowe’s and local contractors**: **Current system** York **CZF06013CA** 5-ton AC R-410A Outdoor compressor has failed Indoor furnace still works (replaced gas value, motherboard last year) # Option 1 - Home Depot referred contractor / Lennox Lennox **ML13KC1** - 5-ton AC Lennox **ML196UH** - 110K BTU furnace **$15,905 installed** **10-year parts + 5-year labor** # Option 2 - Lowe’s local contractor / Carrier Carrier Performance system **4-ton** \~96% furnace, variable-speed blower **$23,891 installed** **10-year parts + 3-year labor** # Option 3 - Lowe’s local contractor / Ruud hybrid Ruud **RD16AY60AJVCA** - 5-ton variable-speed/inverter heat pump Ruud **R962V1155A24M4SC** - 115K BTU, 96% furnace Dual-fuel: heat pump + gas furnace **$19,084 installed** 10-year parts + 3-year labor The hybrid contractor says it’s a cold-climate system designed for the Northeast and...
Keep reading with a free account
The rest of this post, and every signal for Lennox, is in your free account.
Also quoted as evidence
The Lennox is significantly cheaper but appears more basic, while the Carrier quote seems expensive.
From the post